Detail of "Abolitionist Furnishing Textile", early 1800s







Issue 12 

On Further Review



Purchase Subscribe



Anita N. Bateman
Laurie Anne Brewer
Becci Davis
Jamie Gabbarelli
Bethany Johns
Elon Cook Lee
Kevin McBride
Walker Mettling
Jessica Rosner
Suzanne Scanlan
Nell Painter
Allison Pappas
Pamela A. Parmal
Shiyanthi Thavapalan
Nick White


Issue 12—On Further Review



Nell Painter urges Western cultural institutions to return plundered art, which “demands a recognition of peer institutions led by people of color in formerly colonized nations—a learning exercise that may come as hard as the querying of canonical works.”


From the Files

Laurie Anne Brewer lays out what we know—and perhaps will never know—about the intersection of Indigenous and settler-colonizer cultures in a pair of Innu-style moccasins “made by Scotch family named Campbell.”


Double Takes

Anita N. Bateman analyzes how Ronnie Goodman’s “ability to cultivate an ecosystem of resistance contributes to his exceptional interrelation of form,” with Goodman himself elaborating on the genesis of his Birth of Occupy print.

Pamela A. Parmal and Bethany Johns consider an unfinished early 19th-century sampler. Johns asks: “Can we imagine not finishing as an act of resistance, a reversal of the expectation of feminine perfection? Did this maker run out of interest, ability, time, patience, or life itself?”

Kevin McBride suggests that a ca. 1700 portrait may depict the Mashantucket Pequot sachem Robin Cassacinamon, while Lorén M. Spears explains, “For more than four hundred years the portrait has been identified as Ninigret, and to the Narragansett people it will remain as such.”


Artists on Art

Walker Mettling’s Tracings poster insert follows his research on a printed textile to the Igorot people of the Philippines and the human zoos presented for entertainment at the 1904 St. Louis world’s fair.

Jessica Rosner records visiting the RISD Museum in 10.12.18 (Friday afternoon): “It is almost closing time. The guards are happy but not me. . . . There is so much I want to write, to explain. Now it is dark. I have to go to the grocery store. I can imagine Ree Morton saying that very thing.”

In As Far As We Can Go, Nick White recasts the figures in an untitled John Singer Sargent sketch. “‘I saw the woman get sawed in half in Tunica, at one of the casinos, with him.’ ‘I know. . . . I was there. I just forgot that you were there too.’”



Becci Davis directly addresses works in the collection in Letters to Four Venerable Bodies.


Object Lessons

Suzanne Scanlan outlines how Tynietoy dollhouses and miniature furniture shaped taste, “narrowing the gap between public display and private domain.”

Researching an abolitionist textile, Elon Cook Lee unravels narratives of violence and activism, weaving “a tale of a painter, a poet, and an insatiable printmaker. But that’s not all.”

“When and why did this lovingly executed drawing cease to be considered precious or valuable?” Jamie Gabbarelli considers Saint George, Antonio Tempesta, and the ravages of time.


From the Files

Allison Pappas ponders the Peter J. Cohen Collection of vernacular photographs, asking “What stories are restored when snapshots become part of museum collections? What stories are lost with the anonymity of the photographers and subjects to whom they once belonged?”


How To

Shiyanthi Thavapalan (re)constructs the striding lions of Babylon from the Babylonian Processional Way.”



Issue 12: On Further Review is supported in part by a grant from the Rhode Island State Council on the Arts, through an appropriation by the Rhode Island General Assembly and a grant from the National Endowment for the Arts. Additional generous support is provided by the RISD Museum Associates and Sotheby’s.


RISD Museum Director: John W. Smith
Manual Editor-in-Chief: Sarah Ganz Blythe
Editor: Amy Pickworth
Art Director: Derek Schusterbauer
Graphic Designer: Brendan Campbell
Photographer: Erik Gould
Printer: GHP


Read Online





Cover image:


Abolitionist Furnishing Textile, early 1800s

Gift of Mrs. Constance Wharton Smith